Beverage Menu

Prices are subject to change.

Follow us on Facebook or Twitter for updates on our latest offerings.

HOT BEVERAGES

BAILEYS CARAMEL COFFEE Bailey’s Irish Crème and caramel vodka.         7
NUTS AND BERRY COFFEE Frangelico hazelnut liqueur, Chambord liqueur and cream         7

 

Sutter Cocktails

Apertifs


Red Sangria - Merlot, Aperol, Peach Schnapps, served over ice    8
A delicious thirst-quenching blend to start your night off right.

Negroniweiss - Boardroom Gin, Suze, Dolin Dry Vermouth, served over a large rock, orange peel and Luxardo cherry garnish    10 
A special blend of liquors perfected to ease your palette into a perfect evening.


Signature Dinner Cocktails

Smoke on the Bourbon - Knob Creek Rye, Carpano Antica Sweet Vermouth, Vanilla Extract, Hickory LIquid Smoke served straight up    12
A delicately smoked manhattan to accompany the Cod Chowder to perfect a truly scrumptious evening.
The Forest for the Trees - Old Forester 1870, Bacardi 8, lime juice, Cherry Heering, honey syrup, St. Elizabeth Allspice Dram, Absinthe Mist    14
A split base of bourbon and aged rum nicely complement the dark cherry, citrus, and allspice flavors present in this drink.  A mist of absinthe finishes off this cocktail in a perfect fashion.

New Fashioned - Bulleit bourbon, housemade orange and cherry simple syrup, orange bitters, topped with a bruleed orange slice, served over rocks    11
The candy of cocktails; a special blend of housemade simple syrups with the best of bourbons, a dash of orange bitters, topped with a bruleed orange, that's excellent when accompanied by the Steak Frites.

Old Friend - Old Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey, Carpano Antica sweet vermouth, Cynar Amaro, spieced chocolate bitters, flamed orange twist    12.5
Caramelized orange and spiced chocolate notes complement the stirred, whiskey-forward cocktail.

Green Flash - Lititz Springs Vodka, Yellow Chartreuse, Kinsey Triple Sec, Matcha foam, dehydrated star fruit garnish    12
The delicate balance of bitter and sweet perfected in a cocktail with Matcha green tea topper for the more discerning palate.  Best paired with the Shrimp Fettuccini.

Digestifs

T
iramisu Makin' Me Crazy - Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva, Borghetti Divero Caffe Espresso, Destillare Chocolate Liqueur, Whipped Cream, topped with Cocoa Dust    13
This dessert martini that balances on the bitter and sweet line with just a perfect little kick to keep your night going.  Served with a biscotti to dip into this delicious cocktail.




Pub Cocktails

The Nights Watch    $9
A blend of espresso, Carpano Antica, and Lititz Springs gin sure to keep even the most tired of gin loving crows awake

Coquito    $9
Don Q spiced rum blended with winter ingredients to provide you with a warming, Puerto Rican inspired eggnog

Bullevardier    $12
Four Roses bourbon sets the backbone for this classic blend of vermouth, Apertivo select, and bourbon

Spiced Winter Mule    $10
Sazerac Rye Whiskey set ablaze with with a housemade cranberry shrub and topped off with ginger beer

The Rum Diary    $11
Why is all the rum gone? It's not.  It's all in this drink.  Single Prop coconut water rum, mixed with Belle de Brillet pear cognac, and a touch of Lo-Fi Gentian Amaro

Burning Down the Cabin    $10
Come in from the cold and set your soul on fire.  Elijah Craig, smoked maple simple syrup, and a dash of cardamom bitters

SCOTCH FLIGHT

MUCH BETTER BLENDS
Blends were what made Scotch whisky a global success, and the better blends are still considered the real masterpieces by acclaimed master blenders. Here are three greats           17
Antiquary 21 yr   Incredibly well-integrated, beautifully balanced, a dream blend
Chivas Regal 18 yr   a beautiful aged blend, this effortlessly baloances malt and cocoa sweetness,  light fruit notes, and a soothing oaky spice
Sheep Dip   Fragrant with notes of the coast, tangy, malty, honey, toffee


BLENDED MALTS
Once called “vatted malts,” these whiskies are made of single malts. Only, with none of the grain whiskies that go into blends. A difference that is well worth exploring.           15.75
Compass Box Peat Monster   Aptly named; as smoky as any Islay.
Johnnie Walker Green   A beautiful blending; recently brought back to America.
Monkey Shoulder   Three Speyside malts: Glenfiddich, Balvenie, and the rare Kininvie


ISLAY STARTER
If you're new to Islay whiskies, firstly, it's pronounced “EYE-luh.” Secondly, there's no gentle start to these smoky drams, so buckle up           18
Ardbeg 10 yr   Raw, peaty power from a bold distillery. No holds barred
Bowmore 12 yr   Sweet and delicious heather honey and gentle peat smoke
Lagavulin 16 yr   Heavy smoke supported by rich, aged malt. Classic.

THE ADVANCED ISLAY
When you've gotten the taste for Islay peat, it's time to dig deeper and see what else the island has to offer.         18
Ardbeg Uigeadail   It's the Big One: 54.2% ABV, uncolored, unfiltered, and thumpingly rich with sherry, vanilla, and the coal smoke of Islay peat
Laphroaig Triplewood   A decent balance of flavors and aromas with a full body, smooth texture and a bit of heat on its way down
Bruichladdich Port Charlotte   The smoke arrives first followed by an immense creaminess on the palate, then notes or sherbet lemon emerge

THE OTHER ISLANDS
Islay isn't the only island with a distillery in Scotland. Talisker makes beautiful whisky on the Isle of Skye, and Highland Park ages in 100% sherry casks on Orkney          17
Highland Park 12 yr   Done mostly with Spanish oak sherry casks; fruit, smoke, wood
Highland Park 15 yr   More American oak sherry casks; more vanilla, lighter
Talisker Storm   Well-named. The peat in this one roars and thunders

WOOD MAKES WHISKY
It's a rule of thumb that at least 50% of a whisky's flavor (and all of its color) comes from the barrel. Scotch whisky almost always ages in either ex-bourbon barrels or ex-sherry barrels. Taste the difference           14.5
Auchenstan American Oak   Fruit and spice with the vanilla of American oak
The Dalmore 12 yr   A famously sherry-heavy malt; vinous, orange, even chocolate
Balvenie Doublewood 12yr   A combination of both cask types; taste the blend

MAXIMUM SHERRY
If you really, really like sherry cask-aged Scotch whisky, the fruit, the vinous character, the waxiness, then we have some sherry experiences for you.           18
Highland Park Dark Origins   All first-fill sherry casks make this zesty with wine fruit.
Macallan Double Cask   Light citrus notes and boiled sweets, finished with cinnamon, ginger and toasted apples
Sweet Wee Scallywag   A blend of Speyside malts with an outsized sherry influence and a winning sweetness indeed. Rich, fruity, and as much fun as a spunky terrier

TAKE ANOTHER LOOK
Some malts get overlooked in a rush to older bottlings, or fancy finishes. Take your time! These three are beautiful little classics that reward a quiet contemplation.           17
Edradour 10yr   A lovely little malt from one of the smallest distilleries in Scotland.
Glenmorangie Original   The deliciously layered base for all those amazing finishes.
Cragganmore 12 yr   Approach gently: you'll find honey, fruit, and a breath of smoke.

THE HIGHLANDERS
A selection of distillers from Scotland's west, all a stone's throw from salt water: the elegant Glenmorangie; the exciting Oban; and the full-bodied Ben Nevis          19.25
Ben Nevis   Exudes some beautiful coffee, chocolate, and toffeed peat notes
Glenmorangie Nectar D’or   Finished in sauternes casks for a decadent richness
Oban 18 yr   rich spicy oak, warm spiced cider, salted caramel and golden delicious apples

THE SPEYSIDERS
Speyside is the heart of Scotland's distilling; there are more whisky distilleries concentrated here than anywhere else on earth. There's the giant Glenlivet, the vintage-driven Glenrothes, and the seldom-seen Longmorn          21.25
Glenlivet 18 yr   Baked fruit, sweet grains, firm oak structure: this is whisky architecture
Craigellachie 13yr
Longmorn 16yr   Almost an archetype Speyside; malt-focused, lush, fruity


SCOTCH

ANTIQUARY 21 YEAR      12.5
ARDBEG 10 YEAR      11
ARDBEG UIGEADAIL      12.5
AUCHENTOSHAN AMERICAN OAK      9
BALVENIE DOUBLEWOOD 12 YEAR      11
BALVENIE  CARRIBEAN      13
BEN NEVIS      12.5
BOWMORE 12 YEAR      9.5
BRUICHLADDICH PORT CHARLOTTE      10.5
COMPASS BOX PEAT MONSTER MALT      10.5
CHIVAS REGAL 18 YEAR      11
CRAGGANMORE 12 YEAR      10.5
CRAIGELLACHIE 13 YEAR       11
DALMORE 12 YEAR      9.5
DEWARS      8
DEWARS 12 YEAR      9.5
EDRADOUR 10 YEAR      11
GLEN GARIOCH 12 YEAR     15
GLENFIDDICH 12 YEAR      9
GLENFIDDICH 15 YEAR      11.5
GLENLIVET 18 YEAR      15
GLENMORANGIE NECTAR D'OR 12 YEAR      11
GLENMORANGIE ORIGINAL 10 YEAR      11
HIGHLAND PARK 12 YEAR      10
HIGHLAND PARK 15 YEAR      13
HIGHLAND PARK DARK ORIGINS      12.5
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK      9.5
JOHNNIE WALKER GREEN 15 YEAR      10.5
JOHNNIE WALKER BLUE     35
LAGAVULIN 16 YEAR      14
LAPHROIAG TRIPLEWOOD      12
LONGMORN 16 YEAR      15
MCCALLAN 12 YEAR      11
MONKEY SHOULDER      9
OBAN 14 YEAR      13
OBAN 18 YEAR      12
SHEEP DIP      8
SWEET WEE SCALLYWAG      9
TALISKER 10 YEAR      11
TALISKER STORM      11

BOURBON

BASIL HAYDN      10
BLANTON'S      11
BOOKER'S      10
ELIJAH CRAIG       8
JIM BEAM      7.5
KNOB CREEK      9
MAKERS MARK      8
TEMPLETON RYE      9
WOODFORD RESERVE      9

OTHER WHISKEY

BULLEIT RYE      8
CROWN ROYAL      8
MICHTERS RYE      10
SEAGEAM'S 7      7
SEAGEAM'S VO      7
TIN CUP      9

IRISH WHISKEY

BLACK BUSH      10
BUSHMILL      8
JAMESON      8.5
JAMESON BLACK BARREL      10
REDBREAST      11
TULLEMORE DEW      8.5

HOUSE WINE
by the glass...$6.5
WHITE ZINFANDEL
PINOT GRIGIO
CHARDONNAY
MERLOT
CABERNET

WINE CUVEE
1oz      |3oz      |6oz glass


MAMETE PREVOSTINI SASELLA LOMBARDY. ITALY, 2013    3|8|15
PAUL HOBBS CROSSBARN CABERNET, CA 2014          3.5|10.5|21
CHALONE ESTATE CHARDONNAY, CA 2014          2|6.5|12.5
CHALK HILL SAUVINGNON BLAN, CA 2016          2|5.5|10.5
SANOMA LEOB PINOT NOIR, CA 2014          2.5|7.5|15.5
BIBBIANO GINESIO TOSCANA, ITALY 2008          2|6|10

HOUSE SELECT
$ by the glass     |     ($ by the bottle)

SPARKLING, BLUSH, & WHITE
BRUT, Wycliff, CA, NV          6 |(30)
BRUT PROSECCO, Mionetto, ITALY, NV          187ml (10)
ROSÉ, Chateau Figuiere, FRANCE, 2016          9|(34)
MOSCATO, Lost Angel, CA, 2016          8.5|(33)
RIESLING, Rhine River, GER, 2015          9|(34)
SAUVINGNON BLANC, Clifford Bay, NEW ZEALAND, 2016          8.5|(33)
FUSION, Waltz, PA, 2016          8|(28)
CHARDONNAY, Kendall Jackson Reserve, CA, 2015          10|(38)
CHARDONNAY, Waltz, PA, 2014          8.5|(32)

RED
PINOT NOIR, Line 39, CA, 2014        9 | (35)
MALBEC, El Portillo, ARGENTINA, 2016         8 | (30)
BARON RED BLEND, Waltz, PA, 2013          8.5 | (33)
ZINFANDEL, Montoya, CA, 2014         9.5 | (36)
CABERNET, The Crusher, CA, 2015         9 | (35)

WINES BY THE BOTTLE
SPARKLING
BLANC DE NOIRS, Chardon, CA, NV         (45)
BRUT, Dom Perignon, FRANCE, 2006         (200)
BRUT, Veuve Clicquot, FRANCE, NV         (100)

WHITE
RIESLING, Elk Cove, OR, 2014         (42)
POUILLY-FUME, Domaine de Bel Air, FRANCE, 2014         (50)
SAUVIGNON BLANC, Cannonball, CA, 2015         (33)
SAUVIGNON BLANC, Peter Yealands, NEW ZEALAND, 2016         (45)
SAUVIGNON BLANC, Cakebread, CA, 2016         (70)
PINOT GRIS, Trimbach, Reserve, FRANCE, 2010         (98)
PINOT GRIS, Pike Road, OR, 2015         (40)
PINOT BLANC, Trimbach, FRANCE, 2013         (46)
PINOT GRIGIO, Luisa, ITALY, 2015         (42)
ALBARIÑO, Condes de Albarei, SPAIN, 2015         (34)
CHARDONNAY, Cakebread, CA, 2016         (90)
CHARDONNAY, ZD, CA, 2014         (68)
CHARDONNAY, Textbook, CA, 2013         (46)
CHARDONNAY, Rombauer, CA, 2015         (70)
CHARDONNAY, Chalet Pouilly Fuisse, FRANCE, 2015         (80)

RED
PINOT NOIR, Sean Minor, CA, 2014         (42)
PINOT NOIR, Soter Vineyard North Valley,OR, 2015         (70)
PINOT NOIR, Bourgone Henri Darnat “La Jumalie”, FRANCE, 2012         (66)
MALBEC, La Posta, ARGENTINA, 2014         (45)
MERLOT, Canoe Ridge, CA, 2015         (34)
VALPOLICELLA, La Salette, ITALY, 2014         (48)
ZINFANDEL, Easton, CA, 2013         (48)
ROSSO DI MONTALCINO, Camigliano, ITALY, 2014         (47)
SUPER TUSCAN, Frassinello, ITALY, 2012         (68)
CHATEAUNEUF DU PAPE, Domaine des Saumades, FRANCE, 2013         (110)
RHONE RED, Bonny Doon Le Cigare Volant, CA, 2012         (90)
RHONE RED, Tête-à-Tête, CA, 2012         (50)
CABERNET, Vina Robles, CA, 2014         (50)
CABERNET, Monticello, CA, 2014         (65)
CABERNET, Emily’s Miner, CA, 2014         (95)
BORDEAUX, Chateau Magneau, FRANCE, 2010         (54)


THE SUTTER | 14 EAST MAIN STREET | LITITZ, PA 17543 | EMAIL US